Type 2 diabetes (T2D) has long been thought of as a progressive, incurable chronic disease, largely because traditional means of treatment have had limited potential to reverse the disease.
Newer research suggests reversal is possible through three methods: bariatric surgery, low calorie diets (LCDs), very low calorie diets (VLCDs) and carbohydrate restriction.
Sarah Hallberg, DO, MS of Virta Health recently published a review of 99 original articles examining the evidence for type 2 diabetes reversal using each of the three reversal methods. We have included the advantages and limitations of each summarized below.
Defining diabetes reversal. We have defined reversal as maintaining an HbA1c below 6.5% without the use of glycemic control medications. Metformin was excluded from this criteria because it is not specific to diabetes.
Diabetes reversal intervention 1: Bariatric surgery: The most commonly performed bariatric surgeries in the U.S. include laparoscopic and robotic Roux-en-Y Gastric Bypass (RYGB) or Sleeve Gastrectomy (SG). Anatomically, they both decrease the size of the stomach with RYGB also diverting the small intestine. Bariatric surgery has also been shown to cause alterations in GI hormone releases that may impact eating, hunger, and satiety as well as affect gut microbiota populations.
Advantages of bariatric surgery:
- Unilateral improvement in glycemia following operation
- High rates of T2D remission compared to the non-surgical groups
- Three-year remission rates of up to 68.7% after RYGB
- Rapid blood glucose improvements (within hours to days), which likely represents the enteroendocrine responses to altered flow of intestinal contents (i.e., bile acid signaling and changes in microbiota and their metabolome).
Disadvantages of bariatric surgery:
- Surgery of any type can be associated with complications leading to morbidity or mortality. Complication rates have been stated to be as high as 13% and 21% for SG and RYGB, respectively.
- Significant financial costs of an average of $14,389US.
- Increased likelihood of long-term adverse events.Major adverse events included medication intolerance, need for reoperation, infection, anastomotic leakage, and venous and thromboembolic events.
Diabetes reversal intervention 2: Low calorie diets (LCDs). Several studies have reported successful weight loss with decreased insulin resistance and medication use following a LCD or a VLCD. Total calories per day in studies for VLCDs range from 400-800kcal. LCDs range from 825-1800 kcal per day and the higher range has been shown to be significantly less effective. Research suggests that LCDs are effective in reversing diabetes in the short term (up to two years), especially in patients with a more recent diabetes diagnosis.
Advantages of LCDs:
- Quick improvements in glycemic control.A low-calorie diet of 900 kcal, including 115 g of protein, led to significant improvement in glycemic control attributed to improvements in insulin sensitivity.
- Effective in the short term.A VLCD and gastric bypass surgery were equally effective in achieving weight loss and improving glucose and HbA1c levels in obese patients with T2D in the short term. DiRECT (Diabetes Remission Clinical Trial), a community-based cluster-randomized clinical trial with 306 relatively healthy participants with T2D (given an 825 kcal/day formula for 3-5 months) found that at one year, 46% of patients met the study criteria of diabetes remission (HbA1c <6.5% without antiglycemic medications). This dropped to 36% at two-years.
Disadvantages of LCDs and VLCDs:
- Overall difficult to sustain.In one study, weight loss persisted in the diet-treated patients only for the first three months, indicating difficulties with long-term maintenance. Other studies also reported similar pattern of early blood glucose normalization without medication use, but the improvements were not sustained long-term. One study showed that while a VLCD normalized glucose levels within a week; however at 12 weeks over a quarter of the patients had an early recurrence of diabetes with an average weight regain of 20%.
- Requires substantial caloric restriction. A substantial level of calorie restriction is needed to generate enough weight loss to reverse diabetes. Short-term interventions with moderate energy restriction with metformin (which led to modest weight loss) were less effective in reversing diabetes than standard diabetes care.
- Severe energy restriction may have negative long-term effects.Studies have suggested that the body undergoes physiological and metabolic adaptation in response to caloric restriction, and this may shift one’s energy balance and hormonal regulation of weight toward weight regain after weight loss.
Diabetes reversal intervention 3: Carbohydrate restriction: Before insulin was discovered in 1921, low carbohydrate (LC) diets were the standard of care for diabetes. With the emergence of exogenous insulin, the goal became to maintain blood sugar control through the use of medications instead of preventing elevations in blood glucose by restricting carbohydrates in the diet. In response to recent studies, the idea of preventing blood sugar elevations with carbohydrate restriction has found its way back into the mainstream standard of care.
A low carbohydrate diet typically restricts carbs to less than 130 grams per day, and a ketogenic diet to 20-50 grams per day.
Advantages of carbohydrate restriction:
- Highly effective.In our published trial providing significant support through the use of a continuous care intervention (CCI), we examined using a low carbohydrate diet in patients with T2D, compared with usual care T2D patients. At one year, the HbA1c decreased by 1.3% in the CCI, with 60% of completers achieving a HbA1c below 6.5% without hypoglycemic medication (excluding metformin). Insulin was reduced or eliminated in 94% of users. Most cardiovascular risk factors showed significant improvement. Improvements were not observed in the usual care patients. Another 34-week trial found that a ketogenic diet intervention (20–50 g net carbs per day) resulted in HbA1c below the threshold for diabetes in 55% of the patients, compared to 0% of patients in the low-fat group.
- Does not require calorie restriction.Patients are instructed to carefully restrict dietary carbohydrates, eat protein in moderation, and consume dietary fats to satiety.
- Sustainable with support. The one-year retention rate in our continuous care intervention was 83%, indicating that a non-calorie-restricted, low carbohydrate intervention can be sustained.
- More cost-effective than bariatric surgery.
- More effective than restricting overall calories.A study comparing a non-calorie restricted, very low carbohydrate (<20g total) diet to an energy-restricted low-glycemic diet in patients with T2D found a greater reduction in HbA1c, weight, and insulin levels in the low carbohydrate group. 95% of participants in the low carbohydrate group reduced or eliminated glycemic control medications, compared to 62% in the low glycemic index group at 24 weeks.A small (34 participants) one-year study of an eat to satiety on a very low carbohydrate diet compared to a calorie-restricted moderate carbohydrate diet found a significant reduction in HbA1c between groups, favoring the low carbohydrate group.
Disadvantages of carbohydrate restriction:
- Often requires support. Many of these trials included an educational component, and determining the appropriate method of support may be key to the overall success with disease reversal.
- Results are promising, but longer-term follow-up studies are needed. Follow up studies have shown sustainability at two years, so longer-term studies are needed to determine the sustainability beyond that.
This Post has been condensed from Reversing Type 2 Diabetes with Bariatric Surgery, Very Low Calorie Diets, and Carbohydrate Restriction: A Review of the Evidence
Sarah Hallberg, DO, MS on April 8, 2019. Please copy and paste this link into your search bar https://blog.virtahealth.com/reversing-type-2-diabetes-bariatric-surgery-low-calorie-diets-carbohydrate-restriction/
I invite you to Follow my Blog, Facebook or be added to my email distribution list. My focus is to maximize my physical performance and mental clarity, body composition, and most importantly overall health with a wholesome diet and exercise.
I will bring you compelling articles on Ketogenic and GAPS diets, the Super Slow High-Intensity Exercise Program and supplements.
To follow my Blog, please click the Follow button to receive an email when the next posting is available. Hint: You may have to click the Accept and Close button before follow is available.
I thrive on feedback. Please let me know you are interested in the content by clicking Like, Commenting or sending me a message or email about the Post.
If you wish to contact me by Email, please email email@example.com using this form.
May you Live Long Healthy.
Disclaimer: The content of this email or Post is not intended for the treatment or prevention of disease, nor as a substitute for medical treatment, nor as an alternative to medical advice. Use of recommendations is at the choice and risk of the reader.